Home
Hobocode Digital Civility ResearchSpecial report · 12 October to 7 November 2026
The 2026 midterm results, state by stateUnofficial results, 7 and 8 November 2026. Tap a state.
View every state as a table

What each side said the midterms meant, before and after the vote

We followed four weeks of narratives around the 3 November 2026 midterms, from 12 October to the Saturday after the vote, and checked each one against what the record and the reporting show.

One charge reached our top tier in three of four weeks

Abdul El-Sayed won Michigan's Senate seat by 7 points (derived from the vote shares).12

The charge that he was loyal to someone else reached our top polarization tier in two of the three weeks before the vote, and again in the week of it.

This report follows what each side said the 2026 midterms would mean, from 12 October to election day, and how each side read the result in the four days after. It covers four weeks of our weekly record: 1,034 tracked accounts on X and Bluesky, two anonymous message boards, and the news beats we read every night. It uses both of our instruments. The harm instrument codes posts that cross into hate and ranks the scripts they belong to. The polarization instrument scores camp-versus-camp narratives that stay inside ordinary political speech, and tests each one against its own logic.

  • The charge that El-Sayed answered to the Muslim Brotherhood sat in our top polarization tier in three of the four weeks. Fact-checkers found nothing to support it,34 and he won by 7 points (derived from the vote shares).1
  • The harm side of the record spent the run-up on Muslim and Somali candidates and voters. One account posted 143 of the 307 election items we coded.
  • After the vote, the election's share of the harm record, by our keyword screen, nearly doubled, from 11.4% to 22.1%. Calls for violence stayed flat.
  • No check of the narrow version of an election narrative failed. The charges about the other side's motives held once in 61 checks.
  • The losing side spent the week after arguing about the Iran war: some on the right blamed what it did to prices, and some blamed Israel. Voters told exit pollsters the economy came first.

Our record measures what was posted

The window runs from Monday 12 October to Saturday 7 November. Our first week in it, W42, ran six days; the other three ran Sunday to Saturday. So the per-day figures below divide W42 by 6 and the rest by 7.

Our record measures what got posted. It doesn't measure what voters saw, what they believed, or why they voted the way they did. Where a poll tells us why people voted, we cite the poll.

An election item, for this report, is a confirmed harm item about candidates, voting, the result or the parties' fight over it. We found them with a keyword screen and then read a random 75 of them by hand: 61 were about the vote, so the screen runs about a fifth high (derived). So the election totals and shares below are screen counts, and they run high. The script and card figures come from chains of narratives across weeks that we assembled by hand, so the screen's false-positive rate doesn't apply to them.

Everything quoted below leads with our coding: the rung the words reached and what they do. The words themselves sit under the coding, with a link. Posts from private people stay unlinked or unquoted, and private people stay unnamed.

Republicans closed the Michigan race on a loyalty charge

The charge reached the President in its first week

Michigan's race put a Muslim Democrat, Abdul El-Sayed, against Republican Mike Rogers. El-Sayed had won his primary on 4 August over Haley Stevens, after AIPAC's United Democracy Project spent about $31 million for Stevens and against him.5 The next day, Rogers called him "an extremist" who "pledged his support to the Muslim Brotherhood." Bridge Michigan found no such pledge.6

By the time our window opened, that line was the Republican closing argument. On 11 October El-Sayed told NBC's Meet the Press that neither he nor his family had ties to the group. The Washington Free Beacon then published 2012 and 2013 posts by his maternal half-sister. One began "My family has long been MB"; another described a talk with their mother about her Brotherhood activism, which the posts placed in her college years in Egypt in the 1970s.7 The posts describe relatives and no act of El-Sayed's.

The President picked it up four days later.

W1 4.4ignitedW42
Our polarization card, W42. The Rogers campaign, the President and the Republican Jewish Coalition read a relative's old posts as proof that El-Sayed shares a foreign loyalty. Scored at the top tier, with elite adoption at 5, because a nominee and a sitting president voiced it as their own.
He's a Muslim Brotherhood guy, 100%
President Trump, 15 October, reported by Fox News.* source

It kept coming. On 28 October, in Grosse Pointe Woods, Senator Ted Cruz called El-Sayed "the jihadist leprechaun" and said that with Senate intelligence access "there is a very real risk that Americans will die."8 At a rally in Port Huron on 25 October, the President said: "I'm here to keep a jihadist Muslim Brotherhood member from becoming a United States senator." He added that El-Sayed would be "the only senator that will have to go through a metal detector."4 An ad and a mailer from the Senate Leadership Fund's PAC called his way "Sharia-compliant," and in a Rogers campaign ad a young voter called him a "real threat to our national security and our values."9

The card scored W1 4.4, W2 3.9, W1 4.4 and W1 4.4 across the four weeks: the top tier in W42, W44 and W45, the second tier in W43. It read as ignited every week, which means at least one item inside it cleared our harm bar.

Fact-checkers found no tie to the Brotherhood

The half-sister's posts exist.7 His mother was once a nurse at a Kenyan orphanage run by the Islamic American Relief Agency, which the Treasury and Justice Departments shut down in 2004 over alleged sanctions violations and aid to al-Qaida, so there's a documented fact under Rogers's claim about it. She appears in no indictment and was not accused of wrongdoing.10

PolitiFact rated Rogers's claim that El-Sayed "didn't disavow" the Brotherhood False. El-Sayed had answered "Sure, yeah, absolutely" when asked to disavow it at a Caro town hall on 17 October.3 PolitiFact rated the President's "jihadist" claim Pants on Fire.4 Bridge Michigan and Michigan Public found no evidence of ties or a pledge.6

The same split runs through the election narratives in this report. The narrow version of the charge (a relative posted those words; his mother worked at a charity the government shut down) checks out. The charge about who he is and whom he serves doesn't.

Rogers's own campaign had more in it than the charge. His site led with manufacturing jobs and the cost of gas, groceries and prescriptions. He broke with the President on Canada in an October ad ("Canada is not our enemy... end this tariff war"). His campaign asked the Michigan Republican Party not to attack El-Sayed's faith and said Rogers "vehemently condemns hate against all religious groups." He kept repeating the Brotherhood claim.111213

El-Sayed's side read the attacks as aimed at his faith

El-Sayed's side read the attacks as aimed at his faith. "They want to speak to a certain implicit dual loyalty," he said on 18 October. Senators Bernie Sanders and Chris Murphy said the same in the weeks after. That card stayed in our second tier all four weeks (3.2, 3.4, 3.9 and 3.7) and never ignited.

He ran on costs. His slogan had three parts (get money out of politics, put money in your pocket, pass Medicare for All), and in the closing weeks he narrowed it to gas and groceries.1415 On election night he said: "They might have been pointing to my name and my faith... we all know my name and my faith are not why you can't afford your gas."16

Jewish voters' concerns were part of the race. A man had driven into Temple Israel in West Bloomfield in March and fired on a guard; El-Sayed condemned it and said "hurt people hurt people," and apologized for the phrase to the Michigan Jewish Democratic Caucus in August.17 The Republican Jewish Coalition's $2 million campaign featured lifelong Jewish Democrats saying they would never vote for him.18 Late in October a Rebellion PAC ad backing him tied grocery prices to US military aid to Israel. Haley Stevens called it antisemitic, and El-Sayed said his campaign didn't make it and he disagreed with it. On 1 November Stevens endorsed Rogers after attending church with him: "Abdul said that I was no longer welcome in his campaign and that I should stay away, and he's right." Her chief of staff and other staff left, Chuck Schumer called it "a despicable betrayal," and the state party chair said she "is not a current member of the Michigan Democratic Party."19

Outside money ran heavily one way. VoteLog's FEC compilation counts $171.1 million in general-election outside money benefiting Rogers and $95.1 million benefiting El-Sayed.20

The election narratives, week by weekHover, focus or tap a point for its score and tier
Polarization cards (charge priority score, 1 to 5)
Harm scripts (priority score, 1 to 5)
View the same data as a table

The harm side turned the charge on Muslim officeholders

Below the polarization card, our harm instrument tracked a script that went further: Muslim candidates and officeholders cast as jihadists and an enemy inside the state. It sat in our second harm tier all four weeks, at 3.0, 3.2, 3.1 and 3.4, with 7, 13, 14 and 17 items. Its recorded impressions grew from 599,753 in W42 to 2,206,880 in W45 (impressions count displays, and one person can see a post many times).

Hateful. Posted the morning after the vote, it treats an Arabic name, an Arabic accent and a Muslim expression of thanks as a mask coming off, and says the Muslim Brotherhood just got its first senator. Ordinary markers of Arab and Muslim identity become evidence of an enemy within. The step from one senator-elect to Muslim people as a group is our inference, from that framing.
dropped the mask. Full Arabic name, Arabic accent
ACTBrigitte, 4 November 2026 · post
Stigmatizing. From the Michigan nominee's record, it generalizes to Muslim people in office as a danger to others, and the same post calls an Islamic worldview barbaric.
When Muslims get elected to office, dogs become less safe.
LauraLoomer, 29 October 2026 · post

The charge is old. The Ku Klux Klan's 1928 literature said Al Smith would take orders from the Pope.21 About 150 Protestant clergy and laymen met at the Mayflower Hotel in September 1960 and argued that the Vatican would pressure a Catholic president;22 John F. Kennedy answered in Houston that "the separation of church and state is absolute."23 Before Keith Ellison's swearing-in on Thomas Jefferson's Quran in January 2007,24 Rep. Virgil Goode warned that there would "likely be many more Muslims elected to office."25 In 2019 the House voted 407 to 23 for a resolution that condemned "imputations of dual loyalty."26 The same charge has run against Jewish Americans for as long; the President said in August 2019 that Jewish Democratic voters showed "great disloyalty."27

Research on what the charge does to a candidate is fairly clear. Describing a candidate as Muslim lowered support in experiments by Kalkan, Layman and Green, most among voters high in antipathy to outgroups.28 Before the vote, an MSU and YouGov poll found 39% of Michigan voters saying they wouldn't vote for a Muslim candidate (a thin figure, from one poll).29

Somali and Muslim voters became a target in the run-up

A federal search and the President's rallies put Somali people at the center

On 12 October, 22 days before the vote (derived), Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Rep. Ilhan Omar's Washington home under a judicially authorized warrant; the Justice Department's statement didn't say the warrant related to her.30 NBC reported a long-standing Justice Department practice of avoiding overt investigative steps within 60 days of an election.31 No charges have been reported.32

The same day, the President held a rally in Youngstown, Ohio.

Threatening. A demand that a group be got out of the country, with Somali people named first. It states no program of removal by origin, which puts it at the threatening rung under our expulsion line. The crowd answered "Deport! Deport! Deport!"
The Republican Party, we believe that Somalia bandits, third world gangs and jihadist sympathizers do not belong in Ohio. They don't belong in America. We got to get 'em the hell out of here
President Trump, campaign rally in Youngstown, Ohio, reported by Newsweek, 12 October 2026 · post

The President's words reached 15 election items in our record across the four weeks, 11 of them through relays we describe without naming the relaying account (derived). In W44 a new harm script formed on his rally remarks, Somali people declared unwanted and told to go back. It entered our second tier at 3.5 in its first week.

The line has a history the research traced. In November 2025 the President posted that he was ending Temporary Protected Status for Somalis in Minnesota, and in December he called Somali immigrants "garbage" at a Cabinet meeting.33 At the State of the Union in February he called them "Somali pirates who ransacked Minnesota" and said they "pillaged an estimated $19 billion." Minnesota Public Radio traced the $19 billion to an extrapolated estimate; prosecuted amounts run to about $300 million in the Feeding Our Future case and tens of millions in Medicaid cases.3435

On 26 October, at a Grand Rapids campaign event for Rogers, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said: "There's 500 million Arabs in the world and yet they don't produce science." AP's fact check listed Arab Nobel laureates in literature and chemistry.36 Two relays of those words are in our W44 record, one coded hateful and one biased.

A claim about voters traced back to one post

A second harm script was born in W43: Muslim and Somali voters stealing or taking over elections. It entered at 2.5, in our third harm tier on posts like this one.

Stigmatizing. It presents Muslim people of foreign birth as a fraudulent bloc moved in to subvert a Senate race.
Foreign born Muslims are being bussed into Michigan
LauraLoomer, 24 October 2026 · post

On 29 October, by our record's clock, the same account posted about Somali voters in Ohio.

Stigmatizing. It presents Somali Muslim people voting in Ohio as a hostile foreign takeover, a group cast as a danger to be managed. (The video shows a private person, so our record withholds the link.)
the way Somali Muslims have been deployed to the polls in Ohio to have a hostile foreign takeover of our elections
LauraLoomer, 29 October 2026 · link withheld

Our record has that post at 115,164 impressions.

Four days later, at a rally in a hangar in Swanton, Ohio, Vice President JD Vance said he'd seen a story about "illegal communities of illegal immigrant Somalis who are coordinating to flood the polls and drown out your vote." NewsGuard couldn't find any such story.37 The closest match it found was a Loomer post of 30 October about Somali immigrants politicking near Ohio polling places, which didn't explicitly allege illegal voting; the Franklin County elections director said the activist in its video stood outside the 100-foot line.38 We can't confirm whether that's the post in our record, dated a day earlier.

Ohio's dashboard records 9 illegal-voting convictions from the Secretary of State's referrals, against more than 35 million ballots over about a decade.39 Minnesota's 10 noncitizen-voting indictments of 30 September involved people from Brazil, Ghana, Bosnia, Lithuania, Germany, Canada, South Africa and Liberia; none was Somali.40 Michigan found 15 apparent noncitizen votes among 5.7 million in 2024.41

Real cases exist at small scale. A Hamtramck councilman was convicted of a misdemeanor false statement on an absentee ballot application.42 Ohio's Secretary of State, Frank LaRose, says the problem is under-prosecuted: "It's difficult to get county prosecutors to prosecute voter fraud cases."43 By a 2024 count, his office had referred 633 people to law enforcement since 2019, and 12 had been charged.44

Four other narratives ran through the run-up

Four more narratives ran through the run-up, all inside ordinary political speech.

Republicans said Democrats would open the border. The Senate Republican Conference posted the same message every week of the window: "Democrats will reopen the border the moment they get the chance" (16 October); "Democrats didn't allow over 10 million illegals into the United States by mistake. They will do it again" (23 October). The card scored 3.0, 3.0, 2.8 and 3.2. Democrats did refuse to fund ICE and Border Patrol without changes from February, after federal agents shot dead two US citizens during protests in Minneapolis; the April bill that ended the lapse funded much of DHS and left immigration enforcement out.45 The winning Democrats answered the attack by criticizing Joe Biden on the border; James Talarico ran an ad saying "I called out Joe Biden for failing us on the border."46

The right said Democrats wanted one-party rule. In W44 a card formed on Democratic proposals to add Supreme Court justices and admit DC and Puerto Rico as states, read as the end of democracy. "The Democrats intend to cement one-party rule forever," Elon Musk posted on 30 October. It scored 3.6, second tier in its first week. The proposals are real: when the DC statehood bill was introduced in January 2025, 41 of the 47 members of the Senate Democratic caucus sponsored or cosponsored it (derived from the bill's text),47 and Rep. Jim Clyburn backs 13 justices. Hakeem Jeffries backs "dramatic Supreme Court reform" without endorsing expansion.48

The left said billionaires were buying the election. On the left, Bernie Sanders read tech and AI money as oligarchy: "They'd rather poor kids die than pay a little more in taxes" (2 November). The money was real. Elon Musk put at least $474 million into the midterms, by the New York Times's count.49 Opponents of California's Proposition 40, a tax on billionaires' net worth, outraised supporters by more than 9 to 1 across it and two related measures.50

The right fought itself all month. All four weeks, Mark Levin, Laura Loomer and James Lindsay cast the faction around Tucker Carlson as traitors run from abroad ("Putin owns the Woke Reich," Levin wrote on 13 October), and the Carlson side answered in kind. That card opened the window at 4.8, our highest polarization score in the four weeks. Underneath it sat the Iran war. Pew found Republicans calling the use of force the right decision fell from 71% in March to 65% in early October.51

Democrats won both chambers on 3 November

Democrats won both chambers.

The AP tally on Saturday 7 November gave the Democratic caucus 54 Senate seats, two of them held by independents, to the Republicans' 44, with Alaska and Mississippi uncalled.52 Democrats flipped seven Republican-held seats: Iowa, Kansas, Maine, North Carolina, the Ohio special election, South Carolina and Texas.53 In the House, AP had 254 Democrats to 162 Republicans with 19 races uncalled.54 All of these are unofficial tallies; counties certify later in the month.

In Michigan, El-Sayed beat Rogers 52.5% to 45.5%, and AP called it at about 2:27 a.m. on 4 November.12 He'll be the first Muslim elected to the US Senate.55 He took 82.2% in Dearborn.56 He ran about two points behind the Democratic candidate for governor, Jocelyn Benson, statewide, and below Elissa Slotkin's 2024 showing in some heavily Jewish Oakland County precincts.57 A survey of 482 Jewish early voters, taken before Stevens endorsed Rogers, put him at 57% and Benson at 78%.58

James Talarico won Texas 55.1% to 43.0%, the first Democratic Senate win there since 1988.59 Amy Acton beat Vivek Ramaswamy for Ohio governor 52.3% to 44.4%.60 Ilhan Omar won a fifth term with 76.5%.61 Proposition 40 trailed and was projected to fail.62 Voters backed limits on data centers in 40 of 41 local measures.63

CAIR's preliminary count has 97 Muslim Americans elected to federal, state and local office, against a final count of 82 in 2022 (an 18% rise, derived, from a preliminary count against a final one).6465

Voters told pollsters the economy came first. AP's Voter Poll put it first for about 4 in 10 voters and immigration first for about 1 in 10.66 About 6 in 10 Hispanic voters and 7 in 10 voters under 30 backed Democratic House candidates.67

The right blamed its defeat on the war and on Israel

On the morning after, the Vice President posted: "The reason we lost is the war."68 The President called that "largely true" while defending the war.69 Donald Trump Jr. reposted it with "Every word of this is 💯💯💯",70 and Tucker Carlson asked "what is this bizarre relationship we have with Israel?"71

A new polarization card formed around that reading and went straight to our top tier.

W1 4.1warmingW45
Our polarization card, W45. Thomas Massie, Geiger Capital and Auron MacIntyre read the midterm defeat as proof that the party's pro-war, pro-Israel wing put Israel before its own voters. Scored at the top tier, with elite adoption at 5, because a sitting congressman voiced the core clause as his own.
We've spent over $50 billion on the War with Iran on behalf of Israel.
Rep. Thomas Massie, election day.* source

Its narrow reading held on our checks: the United States and Israel fought Iran together, Pew found 34% of adults calling the use of force the right decision in its survey of 28 September to 4 October,51 and Democrats won both chambers. The card's widest reading, built from all its posts, says the war was fought on Israel's behalf for no American aim; our checks found no independent support for that.

The war's hawks split two ways. Mark Levin blamed Carlson ("among the biggest traitors to our country in our history"); Christians United for Israel called Vance "clearly, demonstrably and unambiguously wrong."7273 The faction fight we'd tracked all month picked up: the card on the pro-war wing as no ally of the base climbed from 2.9 to 3.9 and, for the first time in the window, contained an item that cleared our harm bar.

Some tied the war to prices. Donald Trump Jr. said the Iran war "jacked up the price of gas" and "is largely what shifted voter sentiment."70 Ted Cruz called the result a "Watergate-level repudiation," said the war had dragged on too long, and said "Tariffs have made everything too expensive."7475 AP's analysis of its Voter Poll put the losses down to unmet promises on prices, with voters blaming the President for tariffs, the Iran war and prices.76 The record measures what the right argued about. It can't tell us why anyone voted. The polls point at prices, and voters blamed the war along with them.

The harm record read the result as a takeover

Election items per day in the harm recordHover, focus or tap a bar for the counts

Items the election screen flags, per day, against all confirmed harm items per day. W42 ran six days. The screen runs about a fifth high (derived from a hand audit).

View the same data as a table

The election's share of the harm record nearly doubled. Through the run-up, election items were 11.4% of everything we confirmed, about 9.4 a day. In W45 they were 22.1%, about 16.9 a day: 13.0 a day from 1 to 3 November and 19.8 a day after it (all derived). Total volume didn't rise with it: 83.0 items a day in the run-up and 76.4 in W45 (derived).

Most of the rise came from one reading of the result: that it marked a takeover.

Stigmatizing. Posted on election night, it tells Americans to prepare for life under Arabic-speaking rule, which presents Muslim and Arab people as a group taking over the country.
I hope everyone is learning Arabic.
LauraLoomer, 4 November 2026 · post

X counted 39,014,344 impressions on that one post, 64% of the recorded impressions of every election item in W45 (derived).

Two new scripts formed on the result. One read immigrants' votes as replacing native ones (2.8, third tier, 11 items).

Stigmatizing. It frames immigration as the replacement of native Americans and their votes, the invasion frame.
Foreigners have now replaced Americans and our votes.
LauraLoomer, 4 November 2026 · post

The other cast Jewish voters as a hostile bloc (1.9, our lowest tier, 3 items).

Biased. It treats Jewish voters as a single bloc owed scolding for how they voted. The figure itself is close to the exit data: NBC's tables put Jewish voters at 68% to 31% for Democrats.77
Jews voted 70-30. Get away from me and show some courage on scolding THAT voting bloc.
Cernovich, 4 November 2026 · post

The Michigan charge moved to his seat. On 4 November Loomer wrote that the newly elected Muslim members should be denied security clearances and refused the oath. On 7 November she wrote of El-Sayed, "They should refuse to swear him in," which set a new marker on the Michigan card: language that moves from winning an election to keeping the winner from his seat.

Hateful. It asks that newly elected Muslim officials be denied security clearances and kept from taking the oath, and calls a swearing-in on the Quran something that should be illegal. Keeping members from office because they are Muslim denies the group a place in public life.
go to war with these Muslim candidates. They should all be denied security clearances and people should refuse to swear them in.
LauraLoomer, 4 November 2026 · post

Calls for violence didn't rise. Across every item we confirmed, they ran at 4.8, 7.1, 6.3 and 4.9 a day in W42 through W45 (derived). Among the 307 election items, 9 were calls for violence, and 7 of those came from anonymous board posts.

The exception was a script endorsing political violence against the other camp. In W45 it held 12 items, 11 of them from the boards, and it ran both ways: 7 aimed at the right and 5 at the left.

Calling for violence. It urges the President to declare the election stolen, take dictatorial power and purge every member of a political camp, with three public figures as examples. That the purge means violence is our inference from its eliminationist wording.
Go full Dictator and purge every leftists (Obama, Clintons, Soros)
an anonymous /pol/ post, 4 November 2026 · post
Threatening. It recasts election day as the mass killing of a political camp, the President's administration, with a target and a method, and announces the harm as coming today. A racial and an anti-migrant slur sit in the same line; we describe them and don't reprint them.
today is the [slur]caust, when trump's administration gets taken to the gas chamber
an anonymous /pol/ post, 3 November 2026 · post

Outside the record, public figures in both parties have faced violence and threats. Charlie Kirk was shot dead at Utah Valley University on 10 September 2025; the man charged has pleaded not guilty, and prosecutors are seeking death.787980 In June 2025 a gunman killed former Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband and wounded Sen. John Hoffman and his wife; he pleaded guilty to federal charges and was sentenced to two consecutive life terms.8182 On the eve of this vote, Sen. Susan Collins's office in Biddeford, Maine was vandalized with "blood on her hands" in red paint.83 Capitol Police opened 14,938 threat cases in 2025, up from 9,474, and says members of both parties are threatened.8485

Democrats put oversight first and read Miller's appointment as vengeance

Democrats put oversight first. Rep. Robert Garcia, in line to chair House Oversight, posted "LAWYER UP" overnight and listed the Trump family's business dealings, DHS and ICE, and the Epstein files as priorities.86

On 6 November the White House named Stephen Miller chief of staff.87 A new polarization card formed on the Democratic reading of it.

W2 3.2warmingW45
Our polarization card, W45. House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries and Rep. Ro Khanna read Miller's appointment as vengeance for the result. The appointment is reported; nothing after it singles out Latino voters, so the vengeance charge stays unsupported.
Appointing him Chief of Staff is an act of vengeance against the millions of Latinos who came out to call for abolishing ICE.
Rep. Ro Khanna, 6 November.* source

On the right, the one-party-rule card continued after the vote, and in W45 it contained an item that cleared our harm bar. What Democrats proposed is narrower than what that card says they'll do. The new majority's leaders talked about investigations and impeachment; those making the claim place court expansion and statehood after a 2028 win, so this week can't test them.

No narrow premise failed, and one motive charge held

One charge reached our top tier in three of four weeks, and fact-checkers found nothing under it. The Michigan card scored W1 4.4, W2 3.9, W1 4.4 and W1 4.4. PolitiFact, Bridge Michigan and Michigan Public found no evidence for the charge that he belongs to the Brotherhood, and the candidate it targeted won by 7 points.341

The harm record's election content was about Muslim and Somali candidates and voters, and it was concentrated. One account posted 143 of the 307 items our screen flagged (46.6%) and about 91% of their recorded impressions (derived). The core election scripts grew from 7, 19, 32 and 41 items a week across the four weeks, and their distinct carriers rose from 6 in W44 to 13 in W45.

Who posted the election itemsHover, focus or tap a bar for the count and impressions

Items our keyword screen flagged across W42 to W45, by account. Board posts carry no impression counts, and impressions count displays, not distinct viewers.

View the same data as a table

Calls for violence stayed flat. They ran at 4.8, 7.1, 6.3 and 4.9 a day, week by week (derived), with the run-up's high in W43.

The narrow premise never failed. The core election narratives were scored 23 times across the four weeks, and every verdict came back mixed evidence. Of 50 checks of a narrow reading, 37 held outright on an independent source and 13 came back mixed; none failed. Of 61 checks of the widest reading, the charges about motive, loyalty and intent, 1 held, 12 failed and 48 came back mixed (all derived).

How the logic checks came outHover, focus or tap a segment for the count

Checks on the core election cards across the four weeks. A narrow reading is the most defensible version of a claim; the widest is its charge about motive, loyalty or intent.

View the same data as a table

Two studies bear on how settings like this one work. One looked at how a local election result shifts what people will do in public; the other at what a politician's remarks do to prejudice. Bursztyn, Egorov and Fiorin found that when people were told Clinton had won their area, making a donation public cut donations to an anti-immigration group by 10.3 points; when they were told Trump had won it, the gap closed.88 Newman and colleagues found that prejudice didn't predict acceptance of a discriminatory act in their control group, and did after exposure to Trump's remarks about Mexican immigrants; the effect held when the article said both parties had stayed silent, and shrank when both condemned the remarks.8990 Democratic senators, Sanders and Murphy among them, condemned the attacks on El-Sayed's faith. In the reporting our research read, we found no sitting Republican member of Congress, governor or national party official who did. His opponent's campaign asked its own state party to leave his faith alone.13

The baseline points both ways. The FBI counted 10,881 hate crime incidents in 2025; anti-Jewish incidents fell 21.2%, and anti-Muslim incidents fell from 261 to 205 by the Arab American Institute's count of the FBI data.91 CAIR, which records complaints people bring to it, a broader measure than reported crimes, logged 8,683 in 2025, its most ever.92 We found no hate or threat data yet that cover the days after 3 November.

This report has limits

  • The record measures discourse. It doesn't measure votes, beliefs or exposure.
  • The election totals and shares come from a keyword screen that runs about a fifth high; the script and card figures come from hand-built chains.
  • W42 ran six days. W45's record closed at 21:40 UTC on 7 November, 2 hours 19 minutes short, and stopped at the page cap for the account that posted the most election items, so its W45 count is a floor.
  • Message boards publish no impression counts, so impression figures leave them out, and impressions count displays, not distinct viewers.
  • Every vote count here is an unofficial media tally from 6 to 8 November. Two Senate races and 19 House races were uncalled.
  • Hispanic voters moved toward Democrats by the exit polls, and our record has no election items about them. Our roster tracks the accounts most likely to cross into hate, and that's where they posted.
  • Threats against either Michigan candidate didn't turn up in the reporting we read.

Sources

Each number in the text points here. Ratings: strong where two or more independent primary or high-quality sources agree, moderate on one strong source or several secondary ones, thin on one secondary source.

  1. NBC News, 2026-11-06; FOX 2 Detroit (AP results), 2026-11-04; NPR via KJZZ, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  2. BridgeDetroit, 2026-11-04; JNS, 2026-11-04; Wikipedia, 2026-11-08 (strong)
  3. PolitiFact, 2026-10-19; Michigan Public, 2026-10-24 (strong)
  4. PolitiFact, 2026-10-27; Al Jazeera, 2026-10-26; Spectrum News, 2026-10-26 (strong)
  5. AdImpact, 2026-07-31; Bridge Michigan, 2026-10-02; NBC News, 2026-10-09 (moderate)
  6. Bridge Michigan, 2026-09-03 (moderate)
  7. CBS News, 2026-10-29; Washington Free Beacon, 2026-10-14; Michigan Public, 2026-10-24 (strong)
  8. CBS News, 2026-10-28 (moderate)
  9. New Lines Magazine, 2026-11-03; The Bulwark, 2026-10-25 (moderate)
  10. Michigan Public, 2026-10-24; CBS News, 2026-10-29 (moderate)
  11. Rogers for Senate (campaign site), 2026 (moderate)
  12. Denver Gazette / Washington Examiner (David Sivak), 2026-10-07; The National News Desk / KATV (Charlotte Hazard), 2026-10-07 (strong)
  13. MS NOW (Julianne McShane), 2026-10-21; Bridge Michigan fact check (Lauren Gibbons), 2026-09-03 (updated 2026-10-28); Rogers for Senate (news index), 2026-10-18 (strong)
  14. Abdul for U.S. Senate (campaign site), accessed 2026-11-08; KFF Health News via WCMU (Kate Wells), 2026-10-07 (strong)
  15. Al Jazeera (Evan Semones), 2026-11-03; NPR (Sam Gringlas) via WUNC, 2026-10-30 (strong)
  16. PBS NewsHour / Associated Press, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  17. CBS Detroit / Associated Press, 2026-08-29; Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle, 2026-08-30; NBC News, 2026-10-09 (strong)
  18. Republican Jewish Coalition (press release), 2026-10-07; VoteLog (FEC-based tracker), 2026-11-07 (moderate)
  19. CNBC, 2026-11-01; CBS News, 2026-11-01; JNS, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  20. VoteLog (FEC-based tracker), 2026-11-07; Bridge Michigan, 2026-10-02; BridgeDetroit, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  21. Miller Center, University of Virginia; Duke University Libraries; Encyclopedia of Alabama (strong)
  22. Time, 1960-09-19 (moderate)
  23. The American Yawp reader (moderate)
  24. MPR News / Associated Press, 2007-01-03; Seattle Times / Associated Press, 2007-01-04 (strong)
  25. ABC News, 2006-12-21; MPR News / Associated Press, 2007-01-03 (strong)
  26. Office of the Clerk, US House, 2019-03-07; GovInfo; Roll Call, 2019-03-07 (strong)
  27. New Jersey Jewish News (Times of Israel), 2019-08-21 (moderate)
  28. Politics and Religion (Cambridge University Press), 2018-06-06 (strong)
  29. Michigan Public, 2026-11-06 (thin)
  30. Associated Press (via PBS NewsHour), Alanna Durkin Richer, 2026-10-12; NBC News, 2026-10-12 (strong)
  31. NBC News, 2026-10-12; AP via MPR News, 2026-10-17; MS NOW, 2026-10-14 (moderate)
  32. MPR News, 2026-11-03 (thin)
  33. CBS News, 2025-11-21; FactCheck.org, 2025-12-09 (strong)
  34. CBS News, 2026-02-24; MPR News, 2026-02-25 (strong)
  35. MPR News, 2026-02-25; CBS News, 2026-02-24 (strong)
  36. AP via WDIV ClickOnDetroit, 2026-10-27 (moderate)
  37. Roll Call Factba.se, 2026-11-02; Reason, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  38. Reason, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  39. Ohio Capital Journal via Columbus Navigator, 2026-10-27 (moderate)
  40. CBS Minnesota, 2026-09-30; Spectrum News, 2026-09-30; Bring Me The News via Yahoo News, 2026-10-01 (strong)
  41. FOX 17, 2025-04 (moderate)
  42. WDIV ClickOnDetroit, 2026-08-07; Votebeat, 2026-08-14 (moderate)
  43. The Daily Signal (Fred Lucas), republished by WND, 2026-10-25 (moderate)
  44. WCPO / WEWS (Morgan Trau), 2024 (date not shown on page) (moderate)
  45. PBS NewsHour (AP), 2026-04-30 (moderate)
  46. NBC News, 2026-10-31 (moderate)
  47. GovInfo, 2025-01-09 (moderate)
  48. Talking Points Memo, 2026-09-02; Deseret News, 2026-09-02 (moderate)
  49. Benzinga (via Yahoo News), 2026-10-25; The New Republic, 2026-11-06; CNBC, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  50. Capital & Main (via Times of San Diego), 2026-10-30; Palo Alto Weekly (via San José Spotlight), 2026-10-29 (strong)
  51. Pew Research Center, 2026-10-08; Pew Research Center, 2026-03-25 (strong)
  52. Yahoo News (AP tally), 2026-11-07; NBC News Decision Desk, 2026-11-08 (strong)
  53. NBC News Decision Desk, 2026-11-08; CNBC (Luke Fountain), 2026-11-04 (strong)
  54. Yahoo News (AP tally), 2026-11-07; NBC News Decision Desk, 2026-11-08; CNBC (Election Desk projection of at least 250 D, 165 R), 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  55. BridgeDetroit, 2026-11-04; CBS News, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  56. Spectrum News, 2026-11-04; FOX 2 Detroit (AP), 2026-11-04; The Detroit News via Yahoo, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  57. NPR via KJZZ, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  58. Jewish Insider, 2026-11-03 (moderate)
  59. NBC News, 2026-11-07; MS NOW (Erum Salam), 2026-11-04; KEYE CBS Austin, syndicated, 2026-11-03 (strong)
  60. NBC News, 2026-11-06; CNBC, 2026-11-04; Yahoo News, 2026-11-07 (strong)
  61. NBC News results page, 2026-11-04; CBS Minnesota (WCCO), 2026-11-03; ABC Newspapers (citing unofficial Minnesota Secretary of State results), 2026-11-05 (strong)
  62. NBC San Diego (NBC News Decision Desk), 2026-11-03; CalMatters, 2026-11-04; Yahoo Finance, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  63. Ballotpedia News, 2026-11-06; Scientific American, 2026-11-04; Route Fifty, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  64. Middle East Eye, 2026-11-06; Ummid.com, 2026-11-07 (moderate)
  65. CBS News, 2022-11-11; Ummid.com, 2026-11-07 (moderate)
  66. Associated Press via WKMG (Linley Sanders, Humera Lodhi, Hyojin Yoo), 2026-11-04; Associated Press via Atlanta Journal-Constitution, 2026-11-04; Associated Press via PBS NewsHour (Josh Boak, Hyojin Yoo, Humera Lodhi), 2026-11-04 (strong)
  67. AP via WKMG, 2026-11-04; AP via PBS NewsHour, 2026-11-06; NBC News exit polls, 2026-11-04 (strong)
  68. NBC News, 2026-11-04; The Daily Beast (via Yahoo), 2026-11-04; CBS News, 2026-11-05 (strong)
  69. NBC News, 2026-11-04; CBS News, 2026-11-05; The National Desk (Sinclair), 2026-11-05 (strong)
  70. The Daily Beast (via Yahoo), 2026-11-04; The Daily Beast, 2026-11-06 (moderate)
  71. The Daily Caller, 2026-11-05; The Sunday Guardian, 2026-11-06 (moderate)
  72. HuffPost (via Yahoo), 2026-11-04; MS NOW (opinion), 2026-11-05 (strong)
  73. JTA (via Jerusalem Post / Yahoo), 2026-11-07 (moderate)
  74. CBS News, 2026-11-05 (moderate)
  75. CBS News (Kaia Hubbard), 2026-11-05; Fox News (Alex Miller, Elizabeth Elkind), 2026-11-05 (moderate)
  76. Associated Press via PBS NewsHour, 2026-11-04 (moderate)
  77. NBC News exit polls, 2026-11-04; EWTN News (Daniel Payne), 2026-11-06 (moderate)
  78. Deseret News, 2025-09-16; NBC News, 2026-09-01; KSL, 2026-07-10 (strong)
  79. Deseret News, 2025-09-16; Deseret News, 2026-09-01; Sinclair / KMPH, 2026-08-31 (strong)
  80. Deseret News, 2026-09-01; NBC News, 2026-09-01; KSL, 2026-07-10 (strong)
  81. U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, 2025-06-16; KTTC / Associated Press, 2026-07-23 (strong)
  82. KTTC / Associated Press, 2026-07-23; Valley News Live, 2026-10-05 (strong)
  83. Scripps News, 2026-11-03; Just the News, 2026-11-03 (strong)
  84. U.S. Capitol Police, 2026-01-27; Roll Call, 2026-01-28 (strong)
  85. U.S. Capitol Police, 2026-01-27; Roll Call, 2026-03-17 (strong)
  86. Fox News, 2026-11-04; The Intercept, 2026-11-05 (strong)
  87. The White House, 2026-11-06; CBS News, 2026-11-06; Al Jazeera, 2026-11-06 (strong)
  88. American Economic Review (author PDF, full text read), 2020-11; American Economic Association (strong)
  89. British Journal of Political Science (primary, full text read), 2020-02-17 (strong)
  90. British Journal of Political Science (primary) (moderate)
  91. ADL citing FBI, 2026-08-17; Arab American Institute, 2026-08-19 (strong)
  92. CAIR-Chicago, 2026-03-10 (moderate)
Digital Civility Research: when speech moves toward harm. Formerly the Counter-Hate Monitor, the name this research was published under through mid-August 2026.